Skip to product information
DESCRIPTION
A bag stuffed with awesome.
📦 Examples from our rotating assortment — while supplies last, not guaranteed in your bag.
The Dreadful Surprise Mystery Bag is here just in time for Fall/Winter.
Choose your color: Orange, Blue, Red or Silver. Each tier includes mystery full-size Plushie Dreadfuls plus color-coded pouches filled with strange little treasures.
The deeper the color, the greater the value.
You may find mini plush, keychains, pins, patches, clothing, accessories, stationery and other curious things from the Dreadfuls vault.
MYSTERY BAG EXCLUSIVES
Discover exclusive items hidden in select bags — not sold separately in our store.
Some surprises may be rare, retiring, limited or unreleased.
You choose the color. Magic chooses the rest.
Choose Your Dread Level
🟠 ORANGE — $29.99
1 mystery full-size plush + an Orange surprise pouch
$50+ guaranteed value
🔵 BLUE — $59.99
1 mystery full-size plush + a Blue surprise pouch
$100+ guaranteed value
🔴 RED — $89.99
2 unique mystery full-size plushies + a Red surprise pouch
$150+ guaranteed value
⚪ SILVER — $150.00
2 unique mystery full-size plushies + a Silver surprise pouch
Includes guaranteed special piece valued at $50
$250+ guaranteed value
What Hides Inside?
Surprise pouches contain smaller items selected from a rotating assortment. Contents and item counts vary by tier and value.
Full-size plushies are vacuum sealed and packed separately from the surprise pouches.
A Note for Old Friends
Remember the old “Grab Bag of Suck But Actually Awesome”?
We do.
The mystery remains. The plushies are still waiting inside their little vacuum-sealed suck bags. But the bags have improved. Now there are four colors, stranger treasures and, deep inside Silver, a piece of something really special waiting to be found.
The old bag grew wings.
Welcome back.
Fine Print: Contents are selected at random and cannot be requested or exchanged based on preference. Pack-in items and quantities may vary. No-duplicate protection applies only to full-size plushies packed together in the same order. Separate orders may contain the same design. Product photos show examples only and do not guarantee specific items unless stated above. All related products are final sale except where an item arrives damaged or defective. Retail value is based on listed product prices when each batch is packed.
Discount codes cannot be used on Dreadful Surprise Mystery Bags.
SHIPPING & RETURNS
Returns and Exchanges Policy
Most items can be returned for exchange or refund, subject to our Terms and Conditions. Full details can be found under Terms and Conditions and in our Terms of Service. By completing a purchase at Mysterious you agree to our Terms and Conditions.
Shipping and Tracking
We offer FREE shipping to most locations in the world on orders over $60 USD on select products.
**Update – April 2025**
Due to newly imposed tariffs by the U.S. government, the shipping fee for parcels to the United States is now based on weight and starting at a minimum of $15 USD. This fee includes all applicable taxes and import duties, ensuring that no additional charges will be incurred by customers upon delivery.
Free Shipping for the USA is now only for orders over $200 USD in total.
We will continue to monitor the situation and adjust shipping rates accordingly should any changes in trade policies allow for a reduction in costs.
Some items are provided by a third party (indicated on product page) who control the shipping fees and therefore cannot be included in the free shipping.
For orders less than $60 USD, we apply a flat rate shipping cost based on weight: Less than 1lbs (0.45kg) = $9 USD; Greater than 1lbs (0.45kg) = $15 USD (Remote and hard to ship to countries, including but not limited to Iceland and Mexico, have a flat rate of $15 USD)
Your order is shipped directly from our locations in Shanghai and Shenzhen, China through a logistics center in Hong Kong and via e-packet mail services like USPS, DHL, and EMS.
Delivery time depends on global events, delivery location, and time of year, with 3 weeks being typical and some situations requiring 2~4+ weeks once shipped.
Please note that once shipped, we have no control over the shipping companies or global logistics slowdowns and delays, and you may potentially see lengthy delivery times and large gaps in tracking movement. Gaps of a week (or more) are unfortunately quite possible especially on international shipping. Local and International holidays, global events, weather, and other "Acts of God" can also create unexpected delays in shipping.
All packages are insured and tracked. And you will receive a tracking number via email when your order is handled and shipped. Tracking number emails often go into Spam Folders - please check yours.
If any item is lost during shipping (not including handling time), meaning there is no sort of tracking update for 4 weeks or more, we will refund your purchase and shipping costs. Because we hand process all orders, handling times can be impacted by our traveling or local holidays.
Explore other plushies
MEET THE SIGNS
ZODIAC PLUSHIES
PLUSHIE FINDER QUIZ
Uncover your latest obsession and add to your collection. We’ll find the perfect plushie for you.
