Skip to content

4 Dreadful Surprise Bags. Choose your mystery. 40% off. → SHOP NOW

4 Dreadful Surprise Bags. Choose your mystery. 40% off. →

Emily the Strange x Plushie Dreadfuls is here. Free pen with every purchase. Shop Now

Emily the Strange x Plushie Dreadfuls is here. Free pen with every purchase.

MORE FRIENDS, LESS DREAD. SAVE UP TO 15% UNLOCK BONUS

MORE FRIENDS, LESS DREAD. SAVE UP TO 15%

PLUSHIES
PLUSHIES
Mental Health Related Plushies
Physical Health & Chronic Illness
Emotion & Personality Plushies
Anxiety Plushies
Plush Keychains & Mini Plushies
Victorian McGee's & Fairytale Plushies
Love & Romance
Zodiac & Astrology
Celestial & Space
Seasonal & Nature
Cryptids & Fantasy
LGBTQIA+
For Your Consideration
Alchemy
Puppets
Plush Outfits & Accessories
ARTWearablesBags & TotesHome & StationeryBooks & GamesStickers & DecalsAll
BEST SELLERS
NEW RELEASES
SALE
BUNDLE & SAVE
FIND MY PLUSHIE
INFO
INFO
About Us
Loyalty & Rewards
Coming Soon
Suggestions
Common Questions & Concerns
Charitable Donations

PLUSHIES Explore All
ART

Wearables

Bags & Totes

Home & Stationery

Books & Games

Stickers & Decals

All

FIND MY PLUSHIE

INFO Explore All

Account

Other sign in options Sign in

Orders
Profile

Account

Other sign in options Sign in

Orders
Profile

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

Home
/ Bags & Keychains & Pins

Bags & Keychains & Pins

Skip to results list

Sort:

Sort: Alphabetically, A-Z

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

86 items

Sort:

Sort: Alphabetically, A-Z

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Filter

Sort:

Sort: Alphabetically, A-Z

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

2 inch Enamel Pin

2 inch Enamel Pin

$ 9.99

$ 9.99
ADHD Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

ADHD Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

$ 24.99

$ 24.99
Anxiety Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Anxiety Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

$ 29.99

$ 29.99
Anxiety Rabbit Reusable Shopping Bag Accessory

Anxiety Rabbit Reusable Shopping Bag Accessory

$ 19.99

$ 19.99
Autism Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Autism Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 18.74

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 18.74
Barista Plush Keychain Accessory

Barista Plush Keychain Accessory

Regular price $ 19.99 Sale price $ 14.99

Regular price $ 19.99 Sale price $ 14.99
Bigfoot Mini Plush Keychain Accessories

Bigfoot Mini Plush Keychain Accessories

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 17.49

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 17.49
Black Anxiety Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Black Anxiety Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

$ 24.99

$ 24.99

Rewards

Earn Pennies as you collect more plushies, write reviews, and other dreadful interactions. The Wishing Well awaits.

LEARN MORE

Black Plaid Love Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Black Plaid Love Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 18.74

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 18.74
Blue Anxiety Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Blue Anxiety Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 19.99

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 19.99
Blue Ice Love Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Blue Ice Love Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 18.74

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 18.74
Bone Organ Izer Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Bone Organ Izer Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

$ 24.99

$ 24.99

Plushie Finder Quiz

Can’t decide? Leave it to the experts. We’ll find the perfect plushie for you.

BPD Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

BPD Rabbit Plush Keychain Accessory

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 18.74

Regular price $ 24.99 Sale price $ 18.74
Bunny Awareness Ribbon Enamel Pin

Bunny Awareness Ribbon Enamel Pin

$ 6.99

$ 6.99
Chaos Bunnculus Bunpip- Mini Plush Keychain

Chaos Bunnculus Bunpip- Mini Plush Keychain

$ 24.99

$ 24.99
Chronic Pain Plaster Enamel Pin

Chronic Pain Plaster Enamel Pin

Regular price $ 9.99 Sale price $ 7.49

Regular price $ 9.99 Sale price $ 7.49

Plushie News

Be the first to learn about our latest drops, and more. Get 10% off your next purchase when you sign up.

Chronic Pain Plush Keychain

Out of Stock

Chronic Pain Plush Keychain

$ 34.99

$ 34.99
CPTSD Plush Keychain Accessory

CPTSD Plush Keychain Accessory

$ 28.99

$ 28.99

1
2
3
…
5

BEHOLD, THE
PLUSHIE UNIVERSE

FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

delightfully dreadful. wonderfully wicked.

PLUSHIE DREADFULS

is a family owned and run business specialising in creating peculiarly patched friends.

SHOP
ON SALE
NEW RELEASES
BEST SELLERS
FIND MY PLUSHIE
FAQS
ABOUT US

CONTACT US

Mysterious LLC
5020 Franklin Drive Suite 100
Pleasanton, CA 94588*

with fullfillment from Shenzhen

© 2026 Mysterious , LLC. All rights reserved

Site by Future Holidays

Refund policy

Terms of service

Privacy policy

Shipping policy

Withdrawal

Privacy settings

Japan Disclosure

Search

Country/Region

Canada CAD $
Germany EUR €
United Kingdom GBP £
United States USD $

No results found

Payment methods

Search